Saturday, November 28, 2020

Nov 30 - TPI Test

 


Hurray for consistency! It turns out I value nearly everything equally, which I'm not too surprised about, I want my students to both understand mathematics and grow into critical, compassionate citizens. I'm also not surprised that Social Reform was the lowest. While I think its important to challenge societal norms, in my teaching style I hope that occurs as a result of a successful mathematics education, rather than a direct result of said teaching. 

Its worth noting that the "Reflecting on Your TPI Results" section suggests taking note of B-I-A discrepancies of 3 or more; which occurs for me in all but the apprenticeship category. Three of those four gaps are of the minimum value of 3 points, so I'm not too concerned about being an inconsistent teacher. I will also point out that my answers to the Action subsection were almost entirely "Usually" because I feel like I don't have quite enough experience to base my answers on pure reflection. 

Saturday, November 21, 2020

Nov 23 - On Textbooks

As a student I always considered my textbook as primarily a source of practice problems, and as a secondary source of information if I didn’t understand something my teacher taught. I don’t think I ever paid much attention to the verbs and forms address, though they still could’ve had a subconscious effect. 

As a teacher I understand the importance of how language can create or prevent connections between students and the subject material. I still think the primary purpose of a textbook (or workbook in the case of gr8 and 9) is as a supplemental source of knowledge and a source of practice problems. 

But in the age of Khan Academy, Wikipedia, etc., I don’t think it should be the only approved supplement. I would in fact argue that textbooks, as a printed resource, are slow to change and adapt to new ways of teaching mathematics, such as the concept of a “thinking classroom”, and so reliance on them should be reduced. They are certainly more accessible for students, due to being provided by the school, but as I saw in my practicum, funding to replace them needs to be found as they age. In the Pre-Calc 11 class I observed, the textbook was supplemented by a duotang containing lessons, practice problems and even practice tests on topics and content which were absent from the textbook. Its creation and use were more economical than purchasing a new textbook every so many years. All of this is to say that a student’s primary source of learning and knowledge should be their teacher, and a textbook used as a supplement should be on the same level as any other vetted resource.

Friday, November 20, 2020

Nov 23 - The Scales Problem


 

Assuming the intent is that the merchant uses the scales once per order, the question is then, what four numbers can be added together, in various combinations, to compose the numbers bewteen 1 and 40. This is impossible, since:

one of the numbers has to be 1g to meet the smallest possible amount

one has to be 2g for the next smallest number

these can be added to get 3g

then we need a 4g weight

now we can make 5, 6, and 7

then we need an 8g weight, which means the highest sum is 15, a far cry from 40.

Alternatively, the puzzle doesn’t specify how the merchant weighs the quantities. In theory then the weights could weigh 1g, 2g, 3g, and 4g, and the merchant could just weigh any herb out in this quantity, up to 10g at a time. For example, if someone wanted 20g of something, the merchant could weight out 10g of it 2 times, or 4g of it 5 times, etc. The weights could then be any values so long as one of them is 1g, to guarantee odd numbers and the smallest amount.

Another possible alternative involves the use of subtraction. If for example I had two weights, one of 18g and the other of 19g, I could measure 1g by weighing out 19g, then replacing the 19g weight with the 18g and removing herbs from the other pan until they balanced, which would be 1g. Are there 4 different numbers bewteen 1 and 40 that with addition and subtraction bewteen them (using each number only once) we can generate every number between 1 and 40?

If so, let’s call them w, x, y, and z. Now, we need to create 40 unique permutations of these numbers using addition and subtraction, to represent every number bewteen 1 and 40.

 

 

Let w > x > y > z, then we get the following table

Permutation #

Permutation

Permutation #

Permutation

1

W

21

W+X-Y

2

X

22

W+X-Z

3

Y

23

W+Y-Z

4

Z

24

X+Y-Z

5

W+X

25

W-X-Y

6

W+Y

26

W-X-Z

7

W+Z

27

W-Y-Z

8

X+Y

28

X-Y-Z

9

X+Z

29

W+Y-X

10

Y+Z

30

W+Y-Z

11

W-X

31

W+Z-X

12

W-Y

32

W+Z-Y

13

W-Z

33

W+X+Y+Z

14

X-Y

34

W-X-Y-Z

15

X-Z

35

W+X-Y-Z

16

Y-Z

36

W+X+Y-Z

17

W+X+Y

37

W+X-Y+Z

18

W+X+Z

38

W-X+Y-Z

19

W+Y+Z

39

W-X-Y+Z

20

X+Y+Z

40

W-X+Y+Z

 

Which may be possible if we can choose correct values of each number.

Given our initial restraints, we have the following conditions to satisfy all the permutations

w + x + y + z = 40 for #33

w > x + y + z for #34

x > y + z for #28

Then w + x + y is the second largest possible sum, 39, which tells us z = 1

From here I spent about 2 hours trying to find a combination of numbers, but a pattern never revealed itself to me. I tried a simpler case, what numbers would I need to create the numbers from 1 to 10, and got two answers: 1, 2, 7 and 1, 3, 6. I couldn’t find a pattern there either, so unfortunately I had to surrender to this problem and look up the solution, which is 1, 3, 9, and 27.

Given that I couldn’t solve it I don’t think it needs an extension, but a contraction to a series of smaller ranges building up to 1-40 could help students find a pattern in advance of this problem.

Monday, November 16, 2020

Nov 16 - Micro Teaching Reflection

Overall I think our lesson went well. We communicated our topic and used the available technology to demonstrate two mathematical processes clearly. I think we were a bit pressed for time, due in part to technical difficulties at the start and the previous group running long. We also took for granted that everyone would know what Kahoot was and how it worked, which was not the case. Based on feedback those who did participate enjoyed it, but not everyone was able to. 

Also, as the hot topic of the breakout room, we could have provided information about applications of polynomial division, though the implication from the structure of our lesson was that such information would be provided either in the previous lesson that introduced the unit, or in a subsequent lesson, after the math has been learned. 

Saturday, November 14, 2020

Nov 16 - Micro Teaching Lesson Plan and Slides

 Slides: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1xvrRcBrUStEmYBxph-g-N0BaR5BgcSY5Him5vE9Cc0A/edit#slide=id.g8748dcdec7_2_2698


Lesson Plan - EDCP 342A - Pre-Calc 12 - Synthetic Division


Lesson Overview: The concept being taught throughout this lesson is factoring higher degree polynomials through the process of Synthetic Division.


Content Objectives (What will the students know at the end of the lesson): 

Students will be able to: 

  • Understand the process of synthetic division

  • Be able to carry out synthetic division on higher degree polynomials as a way to factor the polynomials


Materials:

  • Synthetic Division Slide Show

  • Kahoot!

  • Students will need pen/pencil and paper

  • Students will need access to Kahoot through phone or tablet


Lesson (15 min total, 14 planned, 1 spare)

  • Introduction of presenters, topic and lesson plan (Alexa, 1 min)

  • Review of polynomial long division (Jennifer, 2 min)

  • Process of Synthetic Division (Max, 2 min)

  • Why it works (Jennifer, 2 min)

  • Extensions to the classroom (Alexa, 1 min)

  • Questions? (2 min)

  • Kahoot! Quiz 4 (min)

Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Nov 13 - Giant Soup Can

 



Student bird thinks that research is needed to start this question, as I don’t know the average height of a bike nor the dimensions of the soup can.

On the other hand, depending on required precision, approximations can be made. Or, as teacher bird notes after thinking about the question for a few minutes, the entire thing can be ‘solved’ with variables, and the values plugged in later.

If a normal soup can has height hc and radius rc, and a bike has height hb and length l­b, then based on the photo the height of the tank (length since its sideways) is approximately ht = 2.5lb. Since it has the same proportions as a normal soup can, rc/hc = rt/ht, or we can also try using hb and say that rt ~ 1.5hb. Now I have approximate equations for both r­t and ht and can set up the volume:

Vt = πrt2ht = π (rcht/hc)2(ht) = π(rc(2.5)lb/hc)2(2.5lb) = 15.625π(rc2lb3/hc2)

Research or approximation would be required to determine actual values, as student bird thought, but at this point the question is effectively solved before the research even started.

This question could be extended a few ways. First, no further information could be provided or required, and the question could ask for the scale factor between the tank and the can. Alternatively, more precise ratios could be provided, like the bike’s length is exactly some times greater than the tanks length, and the student could be asked to determine the ratio of the volumes. Finally, the question could turn into a rate of change question regarding how quickly the tank could/would empty

Sunday, November 8, 2020

Nov 9 - Flow

 

I was aware of the idea of “flow” or a “flow state” before watching this presentation. The context I am familiar with is that of competition, for example watching a basketball player make shot after shot after shot in a high stakes game. That is hard to try and replicate in a classroom, so I’m thankful this video was more technical in its presentation and explanation.

Based on the ideas presented in this video, in order to provide our students with the opportunity to enter a flow state we need to provide them with the correct level of challenge to match their skills. A sufficiently challenging mathematics puzzle or problem is one way to achieve this, but I think that requires a base line level of interest that we would have to cultivate first. Alternatively, I think a competitive game of some form would work as well, though then the challenge is to find a sufficiently mathematical game to incorporate into the classroom. Lastly, I think providing a real world, relatable problem, whether current or historical, that students have the skills to solve could be another way to immerse students in the wonder of mathematical problem solving.

I think it is also imperative to prevent students from falling into the more negative categories, namely boredom and apathy. Such prevention would require strong knowledge of each students’ skills, and the potentially time-consuming process of creating unique challenges to meet each student’s skill level. But if the goal is immersion and excitement in the problem-solving process then its an effort we as teachers will need to make.

Dec 19 - Final Reflection

Skemp's article differentiating instrumental and relational mathematics stuck with me throughout the term, and not just in this course. ...