Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Nov 13 - Giant Soup Can

 



Student bird thinks that research is needed to start this question, as I don’t know the average height of a bike nor the dimensions of the soup can.

On the other hand, depending on required precision, approximations can be made. Or, as teacher bird notes after thinking about the question for a few minutes, the entire thing can be ‘solved’ with variables, and the values plugged in later.

If a normal soup can has height hc and radius rc, and a bike has height hb and length l­b, then based on the photo the height of the tank (length since its sideways) is approximately ht = 2.5lb. Since it has the same proportions as a normal soup can, rc/hc = rt/ht, or we can also try using hb and say that rt ~ 1.5hb. Now I have approximate equations for both r­t and ht and can set up the volume:

Vt = πrt2ht = π (rcht/hc)2(ht) = π(rc(2.5)lb/hc)2(2.5lb) = 15.625π(rc2lb3/hc2)

Research or approximation would be required to determine actual values, as student bird thought, but at this point the question is effectively solved before the research even started.

This question could be extended a few ways. First, no further information could be provided or required, and the question could ask for the scale factor between the tank and the can. Alternatively, more precise ratios could be provided, like the bike’s length is exactly some times greater than the tanks length, and the student could be asked to determine the ratio of the volumes. Finally, the question could turn into a rate of change question regarding how quickly the tank could/would empty

1 comment:

  1. Very nice! I appreciate your student and teacher bird thoughts about this one!

    ReplyDelete

Dec 19 - Final Reflection

Skemp's article differentiating instrumental and relational mathematics stuck with me throughout the term, and not just in this course. ...