Tuesday, September 29, 2020

Oct 5a - The Dishes Problem



How could you solve this puzzle without algebra (or at least, without the algebra we are used to)?

I'm glad the question asked for a solution without algebra, because I couldn't extract the algebra from the question, at least initially. 

My non-algebraic solution is as follows:

2 people/rice, 3 people/broth, 4 people/meat, 65 total dishes

Every 4 people is 3 dishes (2 rice + 1 meat)
Every 3 people is 1 dish (1 broth)

Therefore, every 12 people would be 3*3 + 1*4 = 13 dishes
65 total dishes / 13 dishes = 5 sets of 12 people = 60 people

After solving the question I continued to ponder the algebra, knowing there must be a way, and finally had the light bulb moment, using the ratios of the quantities:

1/2 of the total people have rice => 1 rice dish / 2 people => p/2
1/3 of the total people have broth => 1 broth dish / 3 people => p/3
1/4 of the total people have meat => 1 meat dish / 4 people => p/4

p/2 + p/3 + p/4 = 65 => 13p/12 = 65 => p=60

Does it makes a difference to our students to offer examples, puzzles and histories of mathematics from diverse cultures (or from 'their' cultures!)

I think it absolutely makes a difference to offer students historical problems or puzzles, especially from a broad range of topics. In fact, based on conversation from EDST 401, I think its a necessary component of a diverse, representative, multicultural curriculum. Europeans aren't the only group who developed mathematics, and including other cultures/ethnicities work in the field helps to deconstruct the Euro-centric history students like myself grew up with.

Do the word problem or puzzle story and imagery matter? Do they make a difference to our enjoyment in solving it?

I think the story and imagery make the problem or puzzle more relevant and relatable. Those components also bring the problem/puzzle out of near total abstraction, into a more concrete mathematical space. Perhaps most importantly, I think story and imagery help train us (teachers, students, problem solvers) how to apply the abstract mathematics we learn to real world scenarios. That is something I think a lot of students crave from their classes, relevance.



Sunday, September 27, 2020

Sept 28 - Math Art Project Reflection

 


    

Our group selected Margaret Kepner’s “Circle Packing: 20/20 Vision” for our project. Margaret explained to us through email correspondence that she was inspired by the shape packing website Packomania. Initially we had some difficulty in visually discerning the various envelope and packing circles in the piece due to the use of black for both the primary envelope circle, and the composite envelope circles within. Additionally, it was initially challenging to verbally explain the piece to each other. As such, we decided to both alter the colouration of our recreation to be red and pink (chosen randomly, any two colours would work) instead of black and white, and include a black outline for all of the envelope circles. While less abstract looking, it does allow the viewer to spend less time determining which circles are enveloped. 

    Rather than continue the theme of shape packing, which none of us had really encountered in a classroom, we decided to extend the piece mathematically as a visual aid for number factoring. We used the sizes of circles to represent the magnitudes of the numbers, and nested all of a circle’s factor circles into it, all the way down to the circle representing one. In this way there is a clear visual representation of the idea that all composite numbers are multiplicatively made up of smaller numbers. A straightforward crossover to the classroom would be to have students draw such a ‘factoring circle’ for either a given number or a number of their choice. Lastly, there are further extensions possible if being used for a teaching aid. The circles in our presentation pieces are not strictly proportional to one another, simply bigger or smaller, so proportion could be used to illustrate the idea that a large number and a small number can multiply to the same product as two numbers between them. The circles could also be colour coded and used to illustrate the idea of common factors.

The slides for our presentation are available on Jennifer's blog.

Friday, September 25, 2020

Sept 27 - The Role of Representation in Developing Mathematical Understanding

 

    The authors put forward a well reasoned argument, supported by specific examples alongside citations and references to others’ work in the field. The idea of understanding mathematics as a melding of communicating internal representations and internalizing external representations also runs in parallel with the multi-dimensional approach we saw in Jo Boaler’s presentation in our EDUC 450B class. Particularly the authors highlight the importance of social communication for internalizing mathematics, which reminds me of the clip of the classmates openly discussing how to solve a problem. 

    The article includes representations in the form of symbols, language, pictures, graphs, geometry, verbalizations, and abstract thoughts. The only form of representation that comes to mind which is absent, perhaps poignantly, is artistic representations. To clarify, that would be pictures or videos or music which incorporates or demonstrations a mathematical concept or idea without explicitly illustrating it - for example a picture as representation of the idea of 5 objects could just be a picture of five people or things, and thus would not be artistic by this definition. I think representing composite numbers as circles within circles would be an apt demonstration of number theory and factoring, without having to specifically reference any individual number.

Tuesday, September 22, 2020

Sept 23 - Teachers from the Past and Letters from the Future

 Teachers From The Past

My favourite mathematics instructor is my first year, first term calculus professor. He brought an authentic sense of humour to the lecture hall, and his classes were always engaging. He was very comfortable with the subject matter and frequently incorporated historical context into his lectures, particularly Gauss. He also cemented the idea of not using a formula or theorem until you have seen or done a proof for it; a logic which I extend to other facets of life as well.

My least favourite mathematics instructor is my 8th grade "core" teacher (English and Math). She was responsible for teaching me algebra, a subject I turned out to be very good at. As such I grew bored and stopped writing out all my lines of work, simply solving the questions mentally and writing the answers. She reprimanded me, as this was not proper form, but I was stubborn and she couldn't give me a compelling enough reason to follow that instruction. That class is the lowest K12 math grade I received. I wish she had tried to connect with me more, as my stubbornness and disinterest didn't stem from dislike of the subject, just boredom.


Letters From The Future

😃

Dear Mr. Lenko,

You may not remember me, but I was in your grade 11 math class ten years ago. I was reflecting on the influences in my life as I prepare to pioneer the Mars colony, and I wanted to let you know that your love of mathematics and discovery inspired me. Your classes were fun and engaging, and your encouragement to always ask why and question the norm motivated me to pursue my dreams.

See you from the sky,

Marsha Ynoloc


😡

Dear Mr. Lenko,

You may not remember me, but I was in your grade 11 math class ten years ago. I was reflecting on the influences in my life as I prepare to become the CEO of MegaCorpOne, and I wanted to let you know that I’m glad I only had you as my teacher for one course. Your classes were weird and goofy, like you didn’t take things seriously. You were always pushing us to think critically about everything, but that’s so much more work than just riding the corporate ladder up. I guess I’ll never be remembered as fondly as all those dead mathematicians you used to babble about, but at least I have a private jet!

See you from the sky,

Megan Croope

Monday, September 21, 2020

Sept 21 - Exit Slip - Response to Classmate discussion

 Each group seems to have a very similar reply to question 2, and as a member of such a group I agree with them. I think the honest answer to why most students have to learn most math is to learn to problem solve and think critically. Some students will go on to use specific concepts and relationships in their careers, but no one will use all of it (except a math teacher I guess), and that's perfectly acceptable, because it still teaches students how to approach and solve variety of problems.

Saturday, September 19, 2020

Sept 21 - The Locker Problem

 


This is my first encounter with the locker problem. I used a word document to solve it and attempted to record my thought process throughout. I quickly ruled out a strictly computational approach and decided to tackle it from a number theory perspective. I quickly noticed patterns in the multiples and factors as students took their turn and attempted a generalization. The following is a copy of the document:

The Locker Problem

1000 Lockers open, 1000 students

Student 1 closes every locker (multiples of 1)

Student 2 opens (changes the state) of every other locker (multiples of 2)

At this point only all multiples of 2 are open

Student 3 changes the state of every third locker (multiples of 3)

At this point all multiples of 6 are closed, alongside the first locker, which will never be opened.

            All other multiples of 2 and 3 are open

Student 4 changes the state of every fourth locker (multiples of 4)

Look at 12th locker -> open on 2, close on 3, open on 4, close on 6, open on 12

Look at 25th locker -> open on 5, close on 25

Look at 27th locker -> open on 3, close on 9, open on 27

All prime numbered lockers except 1 will be open because they are only touched once

Perfect squares will be closed because they have an odd number of factors

All other lockers will be open because they have an even number of factors

 

Assume the nth locker isn’t prime,

Then its either a perfect square with factors of the form: 1 x n, ai x bi, (Ön), a ≠ b

Or a non-square composite number with factors of the form: 1 x n, ai x bi­­­, a ≠ b

The perfect squares have an odd number of factors; thus, they will always end in the opposite position from their start (open). The remaining composite numbers have pairs of factors which cancel each others state change, resulting in the last change undoing the first, and them being open.


Monday, September 14, 2020

Hello World!

 


Hello everyone, this is my cat (third of four) Aurelia in a box. Enjoy!

Response to Richard Skemp article on Instrumental vs Relational Mathematics

 My first “stop” moment for Skemp’s article occurred on page five, not because of any one particular sentence, but because around that point I realized that the topic of the article was exactly the struggle I have been experiencing with some of the students I tutor. They struggle to solve a problem, like area or volume, and when I try to explain the underlying concept of what area or volume is before asking them for or giving them the formula, they are frustrated or disinterested. My other “stop” moment occurred on page ten with the idea of teaching proportions before teaching circumference. My first memory of encountering proportions (specifically using the Greek letter alpha) is from university, whereas circumference is taught in elementary school. This idea led me to wonder what other concepts would need to be moved around, for example I did not know why the volume of a sphere is what it is until first year university calculus, when I learned integration. Can a student learning volume be expected to understand calculus? Certainly not in an instrumental curriculum, but I wonder what a relational curriculum would look like.

In my opinion instrumental mathematics is inferior to relational mathematics. Relational mathematics provides a more complete picture of the subject, and creates connections between ideas and concepts that may otherwise seem unrelated to students. For example, students learn how to calculate the speed of an object long years before learning what a derivative is. I think the K12 curriculum should be rebuilt from the ground up to teach relational mathematics. This would certainly be a daunting task, but if the result is more students enjoying and pursuing mathematics, or less students fearing and hating it, it would be well worth the effort.

Dec 19 - Final Reflection

Skemp's article differentiating instrumental and relational mathematics stuck with me throughout the term, and not just in this course. ...