Saturday, November 21, 2020

Nov 23 - On Textbooks

As a student I always considered my textbook as primarily a source of practice problems, and as a secondary source of information if I didn’t understand something my teacher taught. I don’t think I ever paid much attention to the verbs and forms address, though they still could’ve had a subconscious effect. 

As a teacher I understand the importance of how language can create or prevent connections between students and the subject material. I still think the primary purpose of a textbook (or workbook in the case of gr8 and 9) is as a supplemental source of knowledge and a source of practice problems. 

But in the age of Khan Academy, Wikipedia, etc., I don’t think it should be the only approved supplement. I would in fact argue that textbooks, as a printed resource, are slow to change and adapt to new ways of teaching mathematics, such as the concept of a “thinking classroom”, and so reliance on them should be reduced. They are certainly more accessible for students, due to being provided by the school, but as I saw in my practicum, funding to replace them needs to be found as they age. In the Pre-Calc 11 class I observed, the textbook was supplemented by a duotang containing lessons, practice problems and even practice tests on topics and content which were absent from the textbook. Its creation and use were more economical than purchasing a new textbook every so many years. All of this is to say that a student’s primary source of learning and knowledge should be their teacher, and a textbook used as a supplement should be on the same level as any other vetted resource.

1 comment:

Dec 19 - Final Reflection

Skemp's article differentiating instrumental and relational mathematics stuck with me throughout the term, and not just in this course. ...