Tuesday, September 29, 2020

Oct 5a - The Dishes Problem



How could you solve this puzzle without algebra (or at least, without the algebra we are used to)?

I'm glad the question asked for a solution without algebra, because I couldn't extract the algebra from the question, at least initially. 

My non-algebraic solution is as follows:

2 people/rice, 3 people/broth, 4 people/meat, 65 total dishes

Every 4 people is 3 dishes (2 rice + 1 meat)
Every 3 people is 1 dish (1 broth)

Therefore, every 12 people would be 3*3 + 1*4 = 13 dishes
65 total dishes / 13 dishes = 5 sets of 12 people = 60 people

After solving the question I continued to ponder the algebra, knowing there must be a way, and finally had the light bulb moment, using the ratios of the quantities:

1/2 of the total people have rice => 1 rice dish / 2 people => p/2
1/3 of the total people have broth => 1 broth dish / 3 people => p/3
1/4 of the total people have meat => 1 meat dish / 4 people => p/4

p/2 + p/3 + p/4 = 65 => 13p/12 = 65 => p=60

Does it makes a difference to our students to offer examples, puzzles and histories of mathematics from diverse cultures (or from 'their' cultures!)

I think it absolutely makes a difference to offer students historical problems or puzzles, especially from a broad range of topics. In fact, based on conversation from EDST 401, I think its a necessary component of a diverse, representative, multicultural curriculum. Europeans aren't the only group who developed mathematics, and including other cultures/ethnicities work in the field helps to deconstruct the Euro-centric history students like myself grew up with.

Do the word problem or puzzle story and imagery matter? Do they make a difference to our enjoyment in solving it?

I think the story and imagery make the problem or puzzle more relevant and relatable. Those components also bring the problem/puzzle out of near total abstraction, into a more concrete mathematical space. Perhaps most importantly, I think story and imagery help train us (teachers, students, problem solvers) how to apply the abstract mathematics we learn to real world scenarios. That is something I think a lot of students crave from their classes, relevance.



1 comment:

Dec 19 - Final Reflection

Skemp's article differentiating instrumental and relational mathematics stuck with me throughout the term, and not just in this course. ...